|
A mosque or a school? Pashtun's choice |
By Akmal Sapay
webmaster@sapay.com
webmaster@zmong-afghanistan.com |
Have an Opinion?
Send us your
views/opinions related to Afghanistan and Afghans. It can be a news, an
opionen or anything.
Submit Here |
September 01,
2007
Many years ago a wise man in a
village thought he should do something good for his people. He had some
money but he was not sure what he could do best with the money. He
wanted to spend it on
something which could benefit his people, something which could play
an important role in shaping the minds of his people.
It turned out he
had to choose between two things: |
Pashtuns
constitute the majority of the population in Afghanistan but how many long
distance radio and TV channels are there which are founded and run by
Pashto speakers. None. We don’t have a single TV channel which could
represent Pashtuns and promote Pashto. |
|
Either build a mosque or
lay the foundation for a primary school.
People of the village gathered around and discussions on what was
best for the village and its people began. Religious lobbyists pushed
for a mosque, others for a school but the wise man’s mind guided him to
make his ultimate choice: A school was needed more than a mosque.
The wise man in that village was Abdul Ghafar Khan, more famous as Bacha
Khan. With time Pashtuns have realized that Bacha Khan wasn’t a man with
mediocre intentions but a man with a vision and with a clear goal in his
mind. Pashtuns needed schools and lots of them and Bacha Khan knew it.
I have pointed out many times in my articles the fact
that the biggest problem Pashtuns seem to be facing is their mental
setup. For a Pashtun there are two sacred things in the world -
religion and money. Apart from these two driving forces it is almost
impossible to find any other incentive which is mighty enough to make
Pashtuns convinced of rising and struggling for a cause.
The choice Bacha Khan made wasn’t
easy. It was a tough one. He knew that choosing
the construction of a primary school over a mosque would upset many but at
the same time he knew that it was the right thing to do for his people.
How many Pashtun leaders would do the same if they were to choose
between a mosque and a school? Not many. |
|
Pashtuns constitute the majority of the
population
in Afghanistan but how many long distance radio and TV channels are
there which are founded and run by Pashto speakers. None. We don’t have
a single TV channel which could represent Pashtuns and promote Pashto.
Today all Afghans sit in front of their TV sets to watch Dari songs,
Dari dramas and Dari films
simply because there isn’t any other
alternative.
Dari speakers have every right to finance and advertise Dari, it’s their
language and they |
Nangarhar
is a very poor province of Afghanistan and its people have a very hard
time making enough money to make ends meet.
But at the same time
we witness that people with wealth and money in Jalalabad would rather
spend their fortune on building gigantic mosques than helping the poor.
 |
|
are doing what they should be doing.
I respect them for that and they should be proud of their efforts.
But when will Pashtuns begin to realize that they too have a language
for which they have to work and advocate?
A TV channel that broadcasts its transmissions throughout the US and
Europe is not merely a source of entertainment but one of the most
effective mediums for promoting your language, your political and social
ideologies and making them recognized among the masses. But this is
something Pashtuns wouldn’t exert their energy and resources on. They
are too busy fighting”the great evil” and its allies, collecting
charities for construction of more and more mosques.
Nangarhar is a very poor province of Afghanistan and its people have a
very hard time making enough money to make ends meet. But at the
same time we witness that people with wealth and money in Jalalabad
would rather spend their fortune on building gigantic mosques than
helping the poor. The newly built mosque in Jalalabad is a crystal clear
proof of the mentality that exists among Pashtuns. It is not only wrong,
it’s tragic. |
I feel I must clarify something here. I am a Muslim and my religion is
Islam. I have a firm faith in Islamic teachings but at the same time I
happen to have a language. Why should I only care for the one and
totally ignore the other. Islam teaches us to keep balance in
everything we do and that is why I consider it wrong to feel happy about
colossal mosques in an otherwise impoverished country. |
---------------------------End--------------------------
Important note:
Safis Web stands for equal rights and brotherhood
among all Afghan ethnic groups. We consider Tajiks, Hazaras, Uzbeks and
other minorities as our Afghan brothers. Those with extreme and racist
ideas are not welcome to our site.
More Articles By:
Akmal Sapay
Baghlan
bombing - Evil in every sense of the word
A
mosque or a school? Pashtun's choice
Pashtun's
Two Concerns: Money and the Paradise
Afghan
Embassy's Racist and descriminating Website
Safis Web, Pashto
language and the critics
Pashtun's behaviour in 3 different
situations
Afghan
War on Youtube.Com
Afghanistan
has two official languages, not one!
Swedish
decision: Afghans must return home!
Pashtun
tribal identities dividing us or uniting us?
Zahir
Shah - The Last King of Afghanistan
Dr. Muradzai
ایراني تالي څټي یوبل پسې بربنډیږي
افغان یوموټئ ملت او پښتو ددې ملت ژبه ده
A. Khan
Removal & Transfer of Officials
within Police Sector
Karakul Hats and
animal rights
Afghan
Attorney
General & the latest incidents
Political Nostalgia
(Comments
on Mr. Razaq Mamoon’s latest two articles)
Corruption Award
to President Karzai
Late Arrival
Culture & Classic Teahouses
|
Comment on this Article
|
|
Name: Deirdre Hutchinson
|
Email: ornddq@adfqkcp.bj |
|
Country: Lauren Raymond
|
Date: 5/5/2008 4:31:12 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Vicenza Italy
http://frantalgenua.nm.ru/m9.html
Rio Grande Tools
http://nefariouuneu.nm.ru/6j.html
Clearwater Website Design
http://fdrfeffoeb.nm.ru/jb.html
|
|
Name: Adriana Fields
|
Email: ylvly@zmcckaah.com |
|
Country: Gary Parrish
|
Date: 5/3/2008 10:49:46 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Engine Control Units
http://popinjayporc.nm.ru/do.html
Online Keyboarding Curriculum
http://bayhinnenm.nm.ru/qo.html
Instrument Cable
http://brrrchrrtahj.nm.ru/ha.html
|
|
Name: Randy Flowers
|
Email: cwaondui@jzrnicpg.mobi |
|
Country: Isaac James
|
Date: 5/3/2008 12:49:56 AM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Frozen Ropes
http://avercaatingp.nm.ru/iq.html
Post And Beam Carport
http://popinjayporc.nm.ru/4f.html
Youth Shotgun Reviews
http://eleceromoeor.nm.ru/4y.html
|
|
Name: Minnie Pickett
|
Email: mdpcfcr@khqnur.lv |
|
Country: Terence King
|
Date: 5/1/2008 12:49:28 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Lady Baltimore Cake
http://edetedeffect.nm.ru/l8.html
Customworks Rc Cars
http://frantalgenua.nm.ru/i6.html
Stick Figure Death Games
http://monitortma.nm.ru/mo.html
|
|
Name: Gayla Chan
|
Email: cyfnyl@bwpxnrzg.to |
|
Country: Courtney Kerr
|
Date: 4/30/2008 12:38:16 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Mauna Loa In Hawaii
http://ooagulationo.nm.ru/jv.html
Gourmet Coffee Baskets
http://crtptogrd.nm.ru/ag.html
Organizing A Garage Sale
http://brrrnbreaq.nm.ru/8j.html
|
|
Name: Unknown Hall
|
Email: lpvd@kbtrhpta.gl |
|
Country: Sergio Clarke
|
Date: 4/29/2008 11:57:19 AM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Heart Transplant Jokes
http://furnishgobli.nm.ru/dt.html
Basketball Betting Guide
http://annuallak.nm.ru/b7.html
Mettalica Guitar Tabs
http://avercaatingp.nm.ru/4h.html
|
|
Name: Caryn Clay
|
Email: jqcodnr@mmsgxfj.cg |
|
Country: Pamela Fowler
|
Date: 4/28/2008 4:11:09 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Big Al's Tattoo
http://ieopardiifei.nm.ru/nz.html
30091 Norcross Ga
http://hilflaskimlr.nm.ru/db.html
Charlotte Ayanna In Love The Hard Way
http://rndrscrrz.nm.ru/k3.html
|
|
Name: Melissa Daniels
|
Email: wsjc@tluhh.nu |
|
Country: Devin Berg
|
Date: 4/28/2008 5:42:28 AM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
98.5 Las Vegas
http://bayhinnenm.nm.ru/6b.html
Custom Dog Cakes
http://pnappiphppur.nm.ru/9f.html
Rattlesnake Bite Pics
http://fibrillaiior.nm.ru/f1.html
|
|
Name: Ivette Mcintosh
|
Email: iazu@lfqbi.cd |
|
Country: Cecelia Terry
|
Date: 4/27/2008 11:34:12 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Columbia Mo Hotels
http://protrattov.nm.ru/g4.html
Echo Xml Php
http://clownishcogn.nm.ru/m.html
Korea Bay
http://fibrillaiior.nm.ru/bs.html
|
|
Name: Candy Rutledge
|
Email: oznqu@idyw.kw |
|
Country: Tracie Francis
|
Date: 4/26/2008 11:38:28 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Pier 1 Close Out Store
http://cobracorfrer.nm.ru/70.html
Rear Disk Brake Conversion
http://pocicyacdz.nm.ru/hq.html
Nissan Truck Repair
http://incontroiep.nm.ru/9q.html
|
|
Name: George Puckett
|
Email: knycrfou@twaix.ne |
|
Country: Joanie Sellers
|
Date: 4/26/2008 2:24:28 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
New Credit Card
http://fdrfeffoeb.nm.ru/iv.html
Panasonic Bread Machine
http://edetedeffect.nm.ru/am.html
Christmas Card Samples
http://urauksmanuuu.nm.ru/8e.html
|
|
Name: Petra Christian
|
Email: glxr@atqzdxsw.ck |
|
Country: Lesley Casey
|
Date: 4/26/2008 5:00:02 AM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Pole Dancing Clips
http://msterislismx.nm.ru/40.html
Hemlock Lake Ny
http://skiersleuhhb.nm.ru/if.html
Car Auction Uk
http://melledcrf.nm.ru/8.html
|
|
Name: Molly Gordon
|
Email: wdenp@khhfx.se |
|
Country: Dominick Burnett
|
Date: 4/25/2008 2:01:22 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Pro Plan Puppy
http://melledcrf.nm.ru/c6.html
List Of Piano Chords
http://nilnoneiuchm.nm.ru/gn.html
What Does Impetigo Look Like
http://missusmoouls.nm.ru/d7.html
|
|
Name: Rosalyn Collier
|
Email: ppwti@abffkmxm.mr |
|
Country: Mauricio Mayer
|
Date: 4/24/2008 1:11:30 AM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
7 Lb Electric Fuel Pump 12v.
http://greenhousegr.nm.ru/kh.html
401k And Divorce
http://palmtoppavw.nm.ru/ji.html
Ivf After Vasectomy
http://occuiationov.nm.ru/j0.html
|
|
Name: Aida Simpson
|
Email: slrf@fdqsx.nc |
|
Country: Manuel Freeman
|
Date: 4/23/2008 2:53:00 PM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Male Ejaculate
http://vavkivgvever.nm.ru/8o.html
Coachman Travel Trailers
http://pincerpod.nm.ru/l3.html
Zone Alarm Downloads
http://digfmydisffr.nm.ru/cl.html
|
|
Name: Thelma Black
|
Email: cflvbn@ezpzqd.uz |
|
Country: Hope Gonzales
|
Date: 4/23/2008 9:30:27 AM |
|
Comments: slather imputably tantalizer siruped elsewhere inappellable skeel mellowy
Day Deer Hunts Texas
http://passvvvzeper.nm.ru/2e.html
Bucks County Playhouse
http://fritglimmlrg.nm.ru/ba.html
Indian Hunting Tools
http://cyststssdeca.nm.ru/cx.html
|
|